Susan Lee's Pies | Barberton's Favorite Pies & Café

Come on in — there's a fresh slice of heaven waiting for you.

For years, neighbors have gathered at our Jefferson Avenue table for pies baked from scratch, coffee that tastes like home, and the kind of hospitality you only find in a place that truly cares.

594 Jefferson Ave

Daily Fresh Baked

100% Homemade

A recipe isn't just ingredients — it's memory, patience, and a whole lot of heart.

Susan Lee's Pies started as something simple: a love for baking and a desire to bring people together over something truly homemade. What began as weekend baking sessions quickly became the kind of place where Barberton residents know they can find comfort on a shelf — literally.

Every pie is mixed, rolled, filled, and baked right here on Jefferson Avenue. We don't cut corners, and we don't use shortcuts. If it doesn't meet our standards, it doesn't make it out of the kitchen. That's the promise we make to every person who walks through our door.

Fresh Daily Baked every morning, never day-old

Local Ingredients Sourced from Ohio farms and suppliers

Made with Care Every pie tells a story

Classic Apple

Our signature pie — tart and sweet apples wrapped in a buttery, flaky crust with a hint of cinnamon. The one that started it all.

Cherry Delight

Bright, juicy cherries in a perfectly balanced sweet-tart filling, topped with a beautiful lattice crust that's pure nostalgia.

Pumpkin Spice

Silky smooth pumpkin filling infused with warm spices, crowned with freshly whipped cream. A seasonal favorite year-round.

Mixed Berry

A garden of strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries in a tender crust. Each bite is a celebration of fresh, local fruit.

Pecan Classic

A rich, gooey pecan filling in a crisp, golden crust. Sweet, nutty, and unmistakably Southern in the best way possible.

Cream Pie

Velvety custard layered in a buttery shell and topped with billows of toasted meringue. Pure comfort in every slice.

Fresh Brewed Coffee

Rich, aromatic coffee brewed fresh throughout the day. Available black, with cream, or with a splash of your favorite milk.

Cappuccino

Espresso meets steamed milk in perfect harmony — thick, velvety foam on top, warm and inviting in every sip.

Loose-Leaf Teas

A curated selection of premium teas — from classic English breakfast to calming chamomile. Steeped to perfection.

Light Bites

Satisfy your hunger with fresh sandwiches, salads, and savory snacks — all prepared with the same care as our pies.

Holiday spiced pie with seasonal garnish

Holiday Spice Pie

A limited-time favorite loaded with warm holiday spices, nutmeg, and a touch of vanilla. Available while supplies last.

Summer Berry Tart

When the berries are at their peak, so are we. A light, refreshing tart showcasing the best of the season's harvest.

Sweet Potato Pie

A Southern classic — creamy, spiced sweet potato in a buttery crust, often topped with toasted pecans. Pure tradition.

Chef's Special

Ask about our rotating special — a new creation that keeps our regulars guessing and excited to visit.

Menu items rotate seasonally. Ask about today's specials when you visit!

We'd love to welcome you

Whether you're stopping in for a quick coffee and a slice of pie or settling in for a leisurely afternoon, our door is always open. Come as you are — you're family here.